Mahindra Scorpio carbon edition vs Tata Safari dark edition – Comprehensive Comparison

Bijesh Nagesh

16 Jun 2025, 03:53 PM

  • Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari detailed comparison.
  • Value analysis for Mahindra Scorpio N Z8L Carbon Edition and Tata Safari Accomplished Plus Dark Variant.

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari – Comprehensive Comparison

This article presents an in-depth comparison of the top-end variants: Mahindra Scorpio N Z8L Carbon Edition and Tata Safari Accomplished Plus Dark Variant. For clarity, these will be referred to as the Scorpio N Carbon Edition and the Safari Dark throughout the article.  

Both models represent the premium segment of Indian SUVs, offering exceptional performance, distinctive design, and a rich suite of features that appeal to both automobile enthusiasts and tech-savvy drivers. 

Below is a concise summary of the approximate ex-showroom prices for these models (on-road prices vary by city). 

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari – Comprehensive Comparison

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Power and Performance

The Scorpio N Carbon Edition comes equipped with a 2198 cc diesel engine that produces 172.45 bhp at 3500 rpm along with a robust 400 Nm of torque within the 1750–2750 rpm range. This powertrain is engineered to deliver a balanced performance that excels in both urban settings and off-road challenges.

In contrast, the Safari Dark features a 1956 cc diesel engine generating 167.62 bhp at 3750 rpm and 350 Nm of torque across 1750–2500 rpm. Its 6-speed automatic transmission ensures smooth gear shifts and refined driving dynamics, making it a great choice for those who demand both performance and comfort.

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Technical Specifications at a Glance

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari – Comprehensive Comparison
For a quick technical comparison, refer to the table below:
SpecificationScorpio N Carbon EditionSafari Dark
Engine Displacement2198 cc1956 cc
Maximum Power172.45 bhp @ 3500 rpm167.62 bhp @ 3750 rpm
Maximum Torque400 Nm @ 1750–2750 rpm350 Nm @ 1750–2500 rpm
Transmission6-speed Automatic6-speed Automatic
Mileage (ARAI)15.42 kmpl14.1 kmpl
Fuel Tank Capacity57 Litres50 Litres
Seating Capacity77
Boot Space460 Litres420 Litres
Drive Type4×4FWD

This table highlights the key differences in performance, efficiency, and capacity, helping buyers align their vehicle choice with their driving habits and lifestyle needs.

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Design and Interior Excellence

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari – Comprehensive Comparison

Both SUVs fuse a rugged yet modern design language with an emphasis on functionality.

The Scorpio N Carbon Edition features bold, angular lines and a muscular stance that underscore its robust character. The cabin is designed for durability and functionality, offering ample space with high-quality finishes that cater to long journeys and practical use.

Meanwhile, the Safari Dark exudes an upscale ambiance with refined styling. Its interior is outfitted with a soft-touch dashboard, customizable ambient lighting, and a state-of-the-art infotainment system.

These elements combine to create an environment that appeals especially to urban drivers and families looking for both comfort and technological sophistication.

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Advanced Safety and Modern Conveniences

Safety and connectivity enhancements are paramount in these premium models. Both variants include a comprehensive suite of features: 

  • Comprehensive Airbag Systems: Providing extensive coverage for driver and passengers. 
  • Superior Brake and Suspension Setup: Optimized disc brakes in the front and well-calibrated suspension systems ensure enhanced stability and control. 
  • Enhanced Connectivity and Convenience: Modern infotainment systems, vehicle stability controls, and customizable drive modes create a smart, secure driving environment. 

Such features reinforce the commitment of both models to offer a high level of performance without compromising safety or convenience. 

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Driving Dynamics and Market Appeal

In terms of driving dynamics, the Scorpio N Carbon Edition is built to deliver an assertive, responsive driving experience. Its robust 4×4 capability makes it ideal for tackling challenging terrain while still being comfortable on city roads. The 6-speed automatic transmission ensures precise gear changes and optimal performance under diverse conditions.

The Safari Dark, on the other hand, is engineered for refined and smooth operation in everyday driving. Its emphasis on seamless transitions and comfort makes it a strong contender for urban commuting paired with occasional off-road adventures.

Both models have been meticulously designed to meet the evolving demands of SUV buyers in today’s competitive market.

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Ownership and Value Proposition

Choosing between these two standout models hinges on individual priorities and intended use.  

The Scorpio N Carbon Edition offers a compelling performance package backed by a competitive price, ideal for buyers seeking robust power and versatile performance.  

The Safari Dark caters to those in pursuit of a blend of luxury, advanced features, and refined driving dynamics—even if its price is slightly higher. 

Key considerations for ownership include: 

  • Service and Maintenance: Both models are supported by extensive service networks and official channels from Mahindra and Tata Motors. 
  • Resale Value: The strong brand reputations in the SUV segment support healthy resale values over time. 
  • Customization Options: Buyers have a range of official accessories and packages available to personalize their vehicles according to their functional or stylistic preferences.

Mahindra Scorpio vs Tata Safari: Final Analysis

The comparison between the Mahindra Scorpio N Z8L Carbon Edition and the Tata Safari Accomplished Plus Dark Variant showcases their respective merits in performance, design, and technology.

Both models offer fact-based, objective insights that assist potential buyers in making an informed decision within the premium SUV segment.

For further details, visit the official websites of Mahindra Motors and Tata Motors.

For the latest car news, auto guides, and detailed vehicle comparisons, check out CarOnPhone.

CarOnPhone is your one-stop destination to see all upcoming cars, latest cars, released cars, and EV Cars, and compare Cars in all Car Brands. Stay tuned and follow us to update yourself on the automotive world.

Mahindra Scorpio N

13.85 Lakh*

Ex-showroom price

Mahindra Scorpio N Variant Image
Available Colors
Engine

2184

Transmission

Manual

Mileage

15

Power Image
Power

130

Scroll to Top